Keeper Help

TheMarlons631  2/27/2017 1:55 PM

12 team roto 5x5 (obp not average). I can keep 5. Here are the players I have and the 2017 value if I decide to keep them. 

Player                           Round

Arenado                       2

Seager                         21

Pollock                         14

Segura                         24

Dahl                             24

Lucroy                          9

Piscotty                        18

Cueto                            4

Archer                          10

Osuna                          14

E. Diaz                          24

W. Davis                      19

Definitely keeping Arenado and Seager...what about the remaining three? Im leaning toward Lucroy, Davis, and Cueto/Archer.

HELP!

-Marlon

rando  2/27/2017 4:12 PM

Cueto and Archer are locks IMO. Pollock or Lucroy are most likely my last pick. We want to see what AJ does early. Davis is worth considering but in my league we overdraft closers and yet the top several are usually 20-25 so it isn't clear how much value you'll get with that. Pollock could be a $25-35 player if he is good to go.

robertscase  2/27/2017 9:10 PM

I think Pollock is a lock at round 14 -- haven't seen anything to indicate he won't be back healthy, but it's something to monitor this spring.

Cueto may or may not be a good keeper at Round 4 depending on what other pitchers are being kept -- you may just be getting equal value there. Same with Lucroy. Segura at 24 seems to be better value to me than either of those two.

And personally I don't like keeping closers, they get replaced and lose their value too frequently.

I would go with Pollock, Archer, and Segura.

rando  2/27/2017 9:35 PM

Oh, need to correct my prior post, saw '2017 value' and thought those were salaries - missed the heading. I would go Pollock, Segura, Davis.