Donaldson for Machado and Keuchel

Mvand  7/20/2015 2:12 PM

This should seem lopsided but Donaldson has 2 more years of keeper eligibility, while Machado and Keuchel have none. My team is very competitive and this trade might just push me over the edge, but I'd hate to let go of 2.5 more years of Donaldson for 0.5 year of Machado if he regresses.

Thoughts?

(Points Per Stat)

Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	L	SHO	QS	CG	HBP	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	CGV	HBPV	BSV
1	3	2	283.25	Max Scherzer		WAS	SP	15		101.2	81	31	28	18	115	8	2.50	7	0	3	0	11	1	0	0	303.60	21.90	0.00	-56.20	57.30	-6.40	-80.90	1.20	-18.10	57.25	3.60	0.00	0.00
2	23	9	232.35	Zack Greinke		LAD	SP	14		88.0	69	30	28	16	86	7	2.84	7	0	3	0	10	1	0	0	264.00	20.10	0.00	-55.60	42.75	-6.00	-69.10	0.90	-16.40	49.45	2.25	0.00	0.00
2	24	10	231.89	Madison Bumgarner		SF	SP	15		95.5	86	36	33	18	99	10	3.13	7	0	4	0	10	1	0	0	286.50	19.80	0.00	-66.40	49.35	-7.40	-85.90	0.90	-18.00	50.25	2.79	0.00	0.00
6	61	21	202.40	Carlos Carrasco		CLE	RP	15		86.4	81	33	31	19	85	8	3.18	6	0	5	0	10	1	0	0	259.20	18.00	0.00	-61.00	42.25	-9.00	-81.40	0.60	-18.50	50.45	1.80	0.00	0.00
8	87	29	191.46	Gio Gonzalez		WAS	SP	14		87.6	82	34	31	32	87	6	3.23	6	0	4	0	10	1	0	0	262.80	18.90	0.00	-62.80	43.30	-7.60	-81.70	0.60	-32.10	48.35	1.71	0.00	0.00
10	119	41	180.42	Kyle Hendricks		CHC	SP	16		80.2	74	32	29	15	57	6	3.29	6	0	4	0	9	1	0	0	240.60	18.90	0.00	-58.60	28.35	-7.20	-73.80	0.60	-15.10	45.05	1.62	0.00	0.00
11	126	45	176.49	Hisashi Iwakuma		SEA	SP	13		85.9	82	39	36	12	70	11	3.74	5	0	4	0	8	1	0	0	257.70	14.70	0.00	-71.40	34.90	-8.60	-82.00	0.90	-12.30	40.10	2.49	0.00	0.00
12	138	49	171.75	Craig Kimbrel		SD	RP	28		28.1	18	7	7	12	43	2	2.18	2	17	2	0	0	0	0	3	84.30	4.80	116.20	-13.60	21.25	-3.40	-17.60	0.00	-11.50	0.00	0.00	0.00	-8.70
12	144	53	170.83	Jesse Chavez		OAK	SP	14		88.5	84	41	37	27	82	10	3.78	5	0	5	0	9	1	0	0	265.50	15.00	0.00	-74.40	40.90	-10.00	-84.40	0.60	-26.90	42.70	1.83	0.00	0.00
14	166	59	162.18	John Lackey		STL	SP	14		89.3	88	42	39	25	70	10	3.89	5	0	5	0	8	1	0	0	267.90	15.30	0.00	-77.20	34.80	-9.40	-88.10	0.90	-25.00	40.70	2.28	0.00	0.00
16	183	66	156.30	Glen Perkins		MIN	RP	27		27.4	23	9	9	4	29	3	2.82	2	16	2	0	0	0	0	3	82.20	4.80	111.30	-17.20	14.40	-3.40	-22.50	0.00	-4.30	0.00	0.00	0.00	-9.00
17	204	80	151.38	Eduardo Rodriguez		BOS	SP	13		77.3	71	34	32	28	67	6	3.68	5	0	4	0	8	1	0	0	231.90	15.30	0.00	-63.20	33.55	-7.60	-71.30	0.60	-28.30	38.90	1.53	0.00	0.00
22	257	111	137.30	AJ Ramos		MIA	RP	30		29.8	16	10	9	14	35	1	2.72	2	12	2	0	0	0	0	2	89.40	5.70	82.60	-18.00	17.30	-3.20	-15.60	0.00	-14.30	0.00	0.00	0.00	-6.60
29	346	151	109.62	Drew Smyly		TB	SP	8		48.6	41	21	19	14	48	5	3.50	3	0	3	0	5	0	0	0	145.80	9.60	0.00	-37.80	24.00	-5.40	-41.00	0.30	-13.60	26.70	1.02	0.00	0.00
30	350	154	107.75	Dellin Betances		NYY	RP	29		28.8	13	7	6	11	43	1	1.97	3	5	1	0	0	0	0	1	86.40	7.80	32.20	-12.60	21.55	-2.20	-13.00	0.00	-10.60	0.00	0.00	0.00	-1.80
Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	L	SHO	QS	CG	HBP	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	CGV	HBPV	BSV
			2665.37	Avg Stats/Total Values				266		1,042.6	908	406	373	265	1,012	92	3.22	70	49	48	3	98	8	0	9	3127.80	210.60	342.30	-746.00	505.95	-96.80	-908.30	8.10	-265.00	489.90	22.92	0.00	-26.10
			1440.12	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				128		515.9	446	189	174	112	524	47	3.03	35	33	23	2	50	4	0	6	1547.70	104.70	227.50	-347.20	262.10	-45.00	-445.50	4.50	-111.80	248.10	12.72	0.00	-17.70

jyang61107  7/20/2015 2:13 PM

If you want to win now then take it as your team seems like a team to win now.  But 2.5 years of Donaldson is hard to pass in your team. Glad he came over to TOR.  

Mvand  7/21/2015 9:49 AM

Thanks, jyang. Anyone else? I'm thinking about trying to swap out Donaldson/Machado for Dozier/Kipnis. Do people like that better?

ken_admin  7/21/2015 11:31 AM

3B should be one of easiest positions to fill each year so Donaldson is not as exciting as say a great SS keeper. All 4 of those hitters are similar in projected rank based on your settings.  Are either of those 2B keepers?

holty85  7/21/2015 12:39 PM

geez your team is stacked, is this a 4 man league? LOL

Mvand  7/21/2015 1:10 PM

@Kslight -- similar deal to the Donaldson/Machado swap. Dozier is a keeper, but Kipnis isn't. Keuchel is not a keeper either, so the owner is trying to acquire keepers for guys going back in the pool next year.

@holty85 -- Lol, thanks. It's actually a 12 team keeper league that allows draft pick trading. I sold a ton of expiring keepers last year for picks this year and kept quite a few good players like Dozier and Donaldson this year.

Mvand  7/22/2015 8:18 AM

Final offer was Kipnis, Keuchel, and Revere for Dozier and Lackey.

Kipnis & Keuchel - not keepable.

Lackey - 1 more year.

Dozier - 2 more years.

Revere - 3 more years.

The main reason I'm hesitating is that a Schwarber/Random 1B/Dozier/Donaldson/Seager infield next year could be deadly. Keeping Revere is just not nearly as exciting.

jyang61107  7/22/2015 11:18 AM

About even trade for the current season.  Doesn't hurt you much in the next 2 years.  Who knows maybe Revere will be in a good team in the future.

ken_admin  7/23/2015 8:09 AM

It does seem fair enough, and it's pretty much Keuchel for the rest of this year in exchange of two more years of Dozier.  This would give you four elite SP so you better win if you do it!