Lucroy, Gattis & Castro: 2 out of 3 ain't bad?

snacks  6/4/2013 3:12 PM

I'm in a Dynasty League, 12 Team, 25 man roster plus large minor league system. We start C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, OF, OF, OF, Util, Util hitters and use 8 Cats:  Runs (R), Hits (H), Home Runs (HR), Runs Batted In (RBI), Stolen Bases (SB), Total Bases (TB), Batting Average (AVG), On-base Percentage (OBP).

I have a dilemma, I currently own Lucroy and Gattis, however Castro is still on the waiver wire and I can't imagine he lasts much longer. Because of the league set ups Catcher is probably the most available position, teams are loathe to carry an extra catcher unless he's young with massive upside, however our minor leagues are littered with top catching prospects.... So, do I drop Gattis, or even Lucroy and pick up Castro based on return this year and long term. I really need him to give me something this year because I am in the hunt, but If I thought Gattis was going to be the next Johnny Bench I'd certainly hold onto him. And while I don't need him to win the league for me, I really don't need him to be a drain on my OBP & AVG either, which is why I went into this season with Lucroy as my starter.

Thanks in advance,

Snacks

12 Teams | 11 Hitters Per Team [8 Active = H HR RBI SB R TB BA OBP] | 13 Pitchers Per Team [8 Active = W SV ERA WHIP SO K/9 QS OBA]

	Own	Round	Rank	Value	PosV	ValueC	Name	Injury	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	TB	OBP	HV	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	TBV	BAV	OBPV
		3	35	0.39	0.00		Aoki, Norichika		MIL	OF	95		400	62	117	36	32	30	0.293	8	18	167	0.359	1.40	-0.97	-1.08	1.29	1.22	0.16	0.78	0.35
		3	36	0.39	0.00		Rizzo, Anthony		CHC	1B	103		391	55	108	56	37	81	0.275	19	6	190	0.346	0.62	1.19	0.62	-0.26	0.48	1.23	-0.45	-0.29
		4	38	0.37	0.00		Carpenter, Matt		STL	1B/2B/3B/OF	98		405	68	117	39	47	79	0.288	9	2	182	0.367	1.35	-0.76	-0.84	-0.83	1.99	0.86	0.44	0.77
		4	44	0.19	0.00		Segura, Jean		MIL	SS	100		406	60	114	40	34	62	0.282	6	21	165	0.341	1.17	-1.25	-0.73	1.65	1.09	0.09	0.02	-0.53
		4	45	0.16	0.00		Kipnis, Jason		CLE	2B	100		399	57	107	46	42	82	0.267	12	21	171	0.341	0.54	-0.21	-0.23	1.63	0.73	0.35	-1.01	-0.53
		4	46	0.15	0.00		Ortiz, David		BOS	1B	82		294	52	86	59	45	51	0.292	17	0	159	0.387	-1.13	0.76	0.84	-1.05	0.15	-0.22	0.52	1.30
		7	75	-0.19	0.00		Gomez, Carlos		MIL	OF	95		350	42	94	52	18	85	0.270	14	23	162	0.315	-0.45	0.24	0.22	1.95	-1.11	-0.07	-0.70	-1.59
		11	121	-0.71	0.00		Gregorius, Didi		ARI	SS	89		371	48	101	37	24	63	0.272	7	3	151	0.319	0.08	-1.07	-0.99	-0.66	-0.31	-0.57	-0.62	-1.51
		11	124	-0.74	0.00		Brown, Domonic		PHI	OF	94		316	41	84	42	30	62	0.267	13	3	147	0.335	-1.26	0.11	-0.61	-0.69	-1.23	-0.78	-0.80	-0.66
		11	131	-0.77	0.00		McLouth, Nate		BAL	OF	79		303	46	79	32	39	57	0.262	8	18	125	0.353	-1.66	-0.83	-1.50	1.24	-0.63	-1.81	-1.03	0.06
		12	135	-0.89	0.00		Eaton, Adam		ARI	OF	70		285	43	80	24	35	48	0.280	4	14	114	0.373	-1.62	-1.56	-2.13	0.77	-0.99	-2.30	-0.08	0.77
		15	172	-1.25	0.00		Hart, Corey		MIL	1B/OF	66		224	32	63	35	19	55	0.280	12	3	114	0.346	-3.01	-0.20	-1.20	-0.76	-2.30	-2.32	-0.07	-0.15
		15	177	-1.30	0.00		Lucroy, Jonathan		MIL	C	79		274	32	75	35	18	42	0.275	9	3	116	0.325	-2.00	-0.79	-1.17	-0.73	-2.28	-2.23	-0.32	-0.92
		17	194	-1.48	0.00		Ozuna, Marcell		MIA	OF	88		319	31	80	37	19	78	0.252	9	3	129	0.297	-1.59	-0.67	-1.04	-0.74	-2.38	-1.61	-1.63	-2.19
		24	284	-2.50	0.00		Gattis, Evan		ATL	C/OF	36		130	17	34	19	12	27	0.259	6	0	61	0.325	-5.35	-1.22	-2.56	-1.08	-4.02	-4.84	-0.51	-0.42
	Own	Round	Rank	Value	PosV	ValueC	Name	Injury	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	TB	OBP	HV	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	TBV	BAV	OBPV
				-8.14	0.00	0.00	Avg Stats/Total Values				1272		4,869	686	1,340	590	452	901	0.275	154	139	2,152	0.343	-12.90	-7.21	-12.41	1.75	-9.60	-14.04	-5.45	-5.21
				-8.14	0.00	0.00	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				1272		4,869	686	1,340	590	452	901	0.275	154	139	2,152	0.343	-12.90	-7.21	-12.41	1.75	-9.60	-14.04	-5.45	-5.21

	Own	Round	Rank	Value	PosV	ValueC	Name	Injury	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	WHIP	K/9	QS	OBA	AB	WV	SVV	ERAV	WHIPV	SOV	K/9V	QSV	OBAV
		1	2	1.60	0.00		Kershaw, Clayton		LAD	SP	21		152.2	131	51	46	39	149	9	2.75	11	0	1.12	8.8	15	0.227	578	1.70	-0.56	3.20	2.56	1.90	0.47	1.50	2.05
		1	8	1.05	0.00		Strasburg, Stephen		WAS	SP	20		123.0	108	46	42	36	130	11	3.10	10	0	1.17	9.5	14	0.230	469	1.22	-0.56	1.47	1.25	1.37	1.17	1.20	1.28
		1	10	0.88	0.00		Harvey, Matt		NYM	SP	20		134.1	118	52	48	46	139	11	3.24	9	0	1.22	9.3	13	0.230	512	0.96	-0.56	1.12	0.35	1.62	1.03	1.16	1.39
		3	30	0.26	0.00		Greinke, Zack		LAD	SP	19		119.1	112	49	45	32	103	11	3.41	9	0	1.21	7.8	12	0.242	462	0.97	-0.56	0.46	0.57	0.64	-0.73	0.96	-0.20
		3	32	0.24	0.00		Bailey, Homer		CIN	SP	20		125.7	119	54	49	35	112	13	3.54	9	0	1.22	8.0	12	0.244	488	1.17	-0.56	0.05	0.29	0.88	-0.54	0.99	-0.39
		4	45	0.10	0.00		Cobb, Alex		TB	SP	20		123.8	118	53	49	33	105	12	3.55	9	0	1.22	7.6	12	0.245	481	0.91	-0.56	0.03	0.35	0.67	-0.99	0.98	-0.56
		5	53	0.03	0.00		Beachy, Brandon		ATL	SP	15		91.7	84	41	37	34	90	9	3.66	7	0	1.29	8.8	9	0.239	353	0.39	-0.56	-0.24	-0.57	0.26	0.28	0.48	0.18
		6	70	-0.07	0.00		Kluber, Corey		CLE	SP	17		102.2	99	48	44	27	96	14	3.85	7	0	1.24	8.5	10	0.249	399	0.45	-0.56	-0.79	0.04	0.45	0.03	0.63	-0.83
		7	73	-0.09	0.00		Medlen, Kris		ATL	SP/RP	19		122.9	119	54	50	33	100	12	3.66	9	0	1.24	7.3	12	0.249	480	0.99	-0.56	-0.34	0.04	0.54	-1.32	0.88	-0.99
		10	119	-0.31	0.00		Pineda, Michael		NYY	SP	13		80.6	77	38	35	28	76	10	3.94	6	0	1.30	8.5	8	0.246	314	-0.12	-0.56	-0.81	-0.66	-0.11	0.02	0.20	-0.43
		14	164	-0.46	0.00		Lackey, John		BOS	SP	18		109.9	108	53	49	35	89	12	4.00	8	0	1.31	7.3	10	0.251	431	0.68	-0.56	-1.26	-1.01	0.25	-1.18	0.60	-1.21
		16	191	-0.52	0.00		McCarthy, Brandon		ARI	SP	14		92.5	95	41	38	15	61	9	3.68	6	0	1.19	5.9	8	0.258	366	0.09	-0.56	-0.28	0.65	-0.54	-2.19	0.32	-1.66
		31	367	-0.76	0.00		Lyons, Tyler		STL	SP	13		77.4	78	38	35	25	53	8	4.08	6	0	1.33	6.2	7	0.256	306	-0.03	-0.56	-1.04	-0.98	-0.74	-1.62	0.15	-1.24
		35	412	-0.79	0.00		Tepesch, Nicholas		TEX	SP	11		62.3	64	32	29	18	44	7	4.19	5	0	1.32	6.3	6	0.260	247	-0.49	-0.56	-1.03	-0.66	-1.01	-1.24	-0.09	-1.22
		49	585	-1.14	0.00		Tillman, Chris		BAL	SP	20		121.0	126	68	62	43	97	18	4.63	7	0	1.40	7.2	10	0.262	481	0.43	-0.56	-3.36	-2.56	0.46	-1.41	0.51	-2.63
	Own	Round	Rank	Value	PosV	ValueC	Name	Injury	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	WHIP	K/9	QS	OBA	AB	WV	SVV	ERAV	WHIPV	SOV	K/9V	QSV	OBAV
				0.02	0.00	0.00	Avg Stats/Total Values				260		1,638.4	1,557	717	660	478	1,442	166	3.62	116	0	1.24	7.9	161	0.244	6,368	9.32	-8.44	-2.83	-0.34	6.65	-8.21	10.48	-6.45
				0.02	0.00	0.00	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				260		1,638.4	1,557	717	660	478	1,442	166	3.62	116	0	1.24	7.9	161	0.244	6,368	9.32	-8.44	-2.83	-0.34	6.65	-8.21	10.48	-6.45

Hailfire4   6/4/2013 5:54 PM

I would keep Gattis for sure. McCann is a free agent and he should be everyday catcher next year. Lucroy and Castro I would just get the youngest one and call it a day.

Constantine9  6/5/2013 10:39 AM

Before this past weekend I would have dropped Lucroy. Now I would keep Gattis and Lucroy instead.

mbuser   6/5/2013 10:58 AM

Yep, Lucroy has hit .378/.417/1.083 over his past 13 games. I'd stay put.

snacks  6/5/2013 6:06 PM

Thanks. And I agree at this point. Standing pat!