Wieters vs. Norris

ajkrouse  6/10/2015 9:46 AM

10 team league, head-to-head, HR-R-RBI-SB-BB

I stashed Wieters away late in the draft, then picked up Norris to fill the void while Wieters healed. Now, I'm thinking of keeping Norris in the everyday lineup. He has been outstanding.

What should I do? I've considered trading high on Norris, flipping him for a buy-low pitcher like Samardjiza maybe. Or maybe keep Norris and trade away Wieters. Or keep both, since neither is a sure thing moving forward. I don't know. What do you think?

(Points Per Stat)

Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	1B	2B	3B	TB	CS	GDP	SF	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	BBV	1BV	2BV	3BV	TBV	KV	CSV	GDPV	SFV
3	25	15	357.80	Denard Span	Day to Day - Questionable - back spasms - missed Tuesday's game against the NY Yankees	WAS	OF	88	6/9/2015 5:01 PM Denard Span was scratched from Tuesday's lineup with a sore back. 6/9/2015 3:22 PM Denard Span (back) is in the Nationals lineup on Tuesday. 6/9/2015 1:53 PM Denard Span said his back is feeling better than it did on Sunday.	401	62	124	39	30	42	0.309	5	14	88	25	6	175	3	6	2	18.40	38.50	28.40	61.50	29.70	88.10	50.60	17.70	87.40	-42.20	-3.10	-18.00	0.80
3	28	18	356.15	Bryce Harper		WAS	OF	94	6/9/2015 9:25 PM Bryce Harper went 2-for-4 with a home run, one RBI and one run scored on Tuesday against the Yankees.	350	56	100	68	57	91	0.287	20	4	60	18	3	184	2	6	2	80.00	68.30	8.40	55.90	56.60	59.70	35.00	9.30	92.00	-90.90	-2.40	-16.80	1.05
4	35	22	346.45	Nolan Arenado		COL	3B	100	6/10/2015 4:45 AM Nolan Arenado went 2-for-4 blasting his 15th home run of the season with two RBI against the Cardinals on Tuesday.	405	59	116	64	20	59	0.287	17	2	70	27	3	199	2	13	5	66.00	63.50	3.40	58.80	20.10	69.60	54.00	9.00	99.30	-58.80	-1.70	-39.00	2.25
4	37	23	345.80	Adrian Gonzalez		LAD	1B	98		392	56	113	67	41	77	0.287	16	1	69	27	0	188	1	9	7	64.40	66.70	1.00	56.40	41.20	69.20	54.40	0.00	94.00	-77.40	-0.50	-27.00	3.40
4	40	26	341.30	Freddie Freeman		ATL	1B	101		395	57	117	62	51	98	0.298	15	4	75	26	1	192	3	9	3	60.80	62.00	8.20	57.30	51.30	75.00	51.60	4.20	95.80	-97.90	-2.50	-26.10	1.60
6	56	37	323.00	Troy Tulowitzki		COL	SS	87		348	59	105	57	39	73	0.302	15	1	67	23	1	174	0	8	5	59.60	56.90	1.80	58.60	39.00	66.70	45.60	2.10	87.00	-73.10	-0.40	-23.10	2.30
8	71	50	310.50	Norichika Aoki		SF	OF	89		389	59	111	32	37	39	0.286	3	17	90	15	4	142	7	6	1	11.60	32.00	34.00	58.60	37.20	90.10	29.60	10.50	70.90	-38.70	-7.30	-18.60	0.60
8	80	53	304.75	Joe Panik		SF	2B	92	6/10/2015 12:46 AM Joe Panik went 2-for-5 with a solo homer during Tuesday’s 5-0 win over the Mets.	387	55	119	40	31	50	0.307	5	2	91	20	3	160	1	5	2	19.60	40.00	4.00	55.20	31.40	91.20	39.20	9.60	79.80	-50.40	-1.00	-15.00	1.15
10	95	65	295.25	Mark Teixeira		NYY	1B	88		331	52	79	57	48	77	0.238	20	1	42	16	1	156	1	8	6	81.20	57.00	2.20	51.50	48.30	42.00	31.60	1.50	78.15	-77.10	-0.60	-23.70	3.20
10	96	66	294.65	Lorenzo Cain		KC	OF	95		398	51	110	54	25	88	0.277	6	23	79	22	3	157	4	8	4	25.60	53.50	45.00	50.60	24.70	79.20	43.80	8.70	78.65	-88.40	-3.70	-25.20	2.20
16	158	105	256.65	Josh Reddick		OAK	OF	82		302	36	81	41	31	51	0.267	12	2	50	15	3	139	2	5	3	48.40	41.20	4.40	36.10	31.40	49.90	30.80	9.60	69.35	-50.80	-1.70	-13.50	1.50
28	271	157	208.25	Devon Travis	Injured - sore left shoulder - is on the 15-day disabled list Projected Return 6/15/2015	TOR	2B	84	6/9/2015 4:41 PM Devon Travis (shoulder) took some swings in Florida on Tuesday.	304	36	82	31	20	55	0.269	7	7	55	16	3	126	3	8	4	29.60	31.20	13.80	35.50	19.50	55.30	32.00	9.30	63.10	-55.30	-3.00	-24.60	1.85
31	310	176	190.55	Derek Norris		SD	C	82		284	33	74	32	33	67	0.262	8	1	48	18	1	119	1	7	1	33.20	32.10	2.60	33.10	32.80	47.50	35.40	2.70	59.40	-67.00	-0.50	-21.30	0.55
32	311	177	190.45	Matt Wieters		BAL	C	76		252	31	63	34	22	51	0.252	12	1	38	14	0	113	1	6	4	46.80	34.10	1.80	30.60	21.60	37.50	27.60	1.20	56.55	-51.20	-0.50	-17.40	1.80
Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	1B	2B	3B	TB	CS	GDP	SF	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	BBV	1BV	2BV	3BV	TBV	KV	CSV	GDPV	SFV
			4121.55	Avg Stats/Total Values				1256		4,937	700	1,395	677	485	919	0.283	161	80	921	281	32	2,223	29	103	49	645.20	677.00	159.00	699.70	484.80	921.00	561.20	95.40	1111.40	-919.20	-28.90	-309.30	24.25
			3117.10	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				919		3,661	524	1,060	523	358	697	0.289	119	54	696	220	24	1,685	18	75	34	476.00	522.70	107.20	523.50	358.20	696.10	440.40	72.90	842.70	-696.90	-17.50	-225.00	16.80

Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	HLD	L	SHO	QS	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	HLDV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	BSV
1	1	1	493.26	Clayton Kershaw		LAD	SP	21		145.8	110	37	34	27	171	7	2.09	11	0	0	3	1	16	0	437.40	54.50	0.00	-67.80	171.40	0.00	-17.00	-109.80	2.40	-27.10	49.26	0.00
5	44	15	337.29	James Shields		SD	SP	21	6/9/2015 11:44 PM James Shields worked 5 1/3 innings in Tuesday’s 6-5 loss to the Braves, surrendering five runs (four earned) on seven hits and a walk while striking out six.	141.3	129	60	55	32	136	16	3.49	8	0	0	7	1	14	0	423.90	40.50	0.00	-109.60	136.20	0.00	-34.50	-129.40	1.50	-32.20	40.89	0.00
5	47	17	334.64	Gerrit Cole		PIT	SP	21		128.6	116	47	43	37	124	9	3.02	9	0	0	5	0	14	0	385.80	46.00	0.00	-86.20	123.50	0.00	-26.50	-115.60	0.90	-36.70	43.44	0.00
7	63	20	317.86	Gio Gonzalez		WAS	SP	21		126.5	120	49	45	45	129	9	3.17	9	0	0	5	0	14	0	379.50	46.00	0.00	-89.20	129.30	0.00	-26.50	-119.50	0.90	-45.00	42.36	0.00
8	75	24	308.55	Lance Lynn	Day to Day - Questionable - tightness in right forearm - is questionable for Saturday's scheduled start against Kansas City	STL	SP	22	6/10/2015 7:31 AM Cardinals sent Lance Lynn (forearm) back to St Louis to get an MRI.	131.9	123	53	49	50	127	9	3.33	9	0	0	6	0	14	0	395.70	44.00	0.00	-97.60	126.70	0.00	-31.50	-122.80	0.90	-49.60	42.75	0.00
17	167	58	251.24	Drew Hutchison		TOR	SP	20		118.0	115	56	52	37	111	14	3.93	8	0	0	7	0	12	0	354.00	38.50	0.00	-103.00	110.50	0.00	-32.50	-115.30	0.90	-37.20	35.34	0.00
24	232	96	224.10	Drew Storen		WAS	RP	46		41.7	32	13	12	9	39	2	2.59	3	27	0	3	0	0	5	125.10	13.50	135.00	-24.00	38.70	0.00	-14.00	-31.50	0.00	-8.90	0.00	-9.80
24	236	98	222.80	David Robertson		CHW	RP	41	6/10/2015 12:00 AM David Robertson recorded his 12th save of the season against the Astros on Tuesday allowing one hit and striking out one.	40.6	29	13	12	11	57	4	2.68	2	24	0	3	0	0	4	121.80	12.00	118.00	-24.20	56.60	0.00	-12.50	-29.20	0.00	-10.90	0.00	-8.80
24	237	99	222.56	Chris Heston		SF	SP	22	6/9/2015 8:40 PM Chris Heston has pitched a no hitter in Tuesday's game against the Mets.	105.5	106	46	42	30	81	8	3.57	7	0	1	5	0	11	0	316.50	37.00	0.00	-83.80	80.60	0.50	-26.00	-105.60	0.60	-29.70	32.46	0.00
25	244	104	219.77	Alfredo Simon		DET	SP	20		118.7	102	59	54	38	77	11	4.09	7	0	0	7	0	11	0	356.10	34.50	0.00	-107.80	77.40	0.00	-33.50	-102.40	0.90	-38.10	32.67	0.00
29	289	125	202.26	Ubaldo Jimenez		BAL	SP	26		94.3	84	43	40	41	94	9	3.79	6	0	1	5	0	8	0	282.90	28.50	0.00	-79.40	93.70	1.10	-24.00	-83.60	0.60	-41.30	23.76	0.00
33	330	145	184.80	Santiago Casilla		SF	RP	44		44.1	35	19	17	16	36	3	3.47	3	22	2	3	0	0	5	132.30	14.00	108.00	-34.00	36.10	1.70	-13.00	-35.40	0.00	-15.90	0.00	-9.00
Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	HLD	L	SHO	QS	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	HLDV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	BSV
			3319.13	Avg Stats/Total Values				324		1,237.0	1,100	493	453	373	1,181	101	3.30	82	72	3	58	3	114	14	3711.00	409.00	361.00	-906.60	1180.70	3.30	-291.50	-1100.10	9.60	-372.60	342.93	-27.60
			1948.16	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				239		717.9	636	302	278	239	663	60	3.49	46	72	3	38	1	59	14	2153.70	231.00	361.00	-556.20	663.20	2.80	-187.50	-635.80	4.20	-238.60	177.96	-27.60

ken_admin  6/10/2015 9:50 AM

We have them about the same the rest of the way, but Norris is the better bet.  Wieters will likely be rested more often since he's coming off an injury, and even when healthy, he's not an elite catcher option.

ajkrouse  6/11/2015 12:54 PM

So who should I drop from my roster since Wieters is now available to play?

ken_admin  6/11/2015 1:59 PM

I assume you'll drop one of the catchers? What are your roster restrictions for pitchers? It looks like SP in general will have more value than RP.

ajkrouse  6/17/2015 1:37 PM

I ended up dropping Lorenzo Cain since I have soo many outfielders. I'm at my limit when it comes to pitchers.

(Points Per Stat)

Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	1B	2B	3B	TB	CS	GDP	SF	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	BBV	1BV	2BV	3BV	TBV	KV	CSV	GDPV	SFV
3	27	17	343.30	Bryce Harper		WAS	OF	87	6/17/2015 1:20 AM Bryce Harper went 3-for-3 with a home run, double, run, RBI and a walk against Tampa Bay on Tuesday.	332	54	98	61	54	84	0.296	19	4	60	17	3	179	3	5	2	77.20	61.40	8.60	53.70	53.60	59.50	33.20	8.70	89.30	-84.10	-2.90	-15.90	1.00
3	30	19	335.95	Denard Span		WAS	OF	82	6/17/2015 1:19 AM Denard Span went 2-for-4 with a run, RBI and walk against Tampa Bay on Tuesday.	376	56	116	35	29	38	0.309	4	14	83	24	5	163	3	6	2	16.80	34.50	28.40	55.70	29.00	83.40	47.00	16.20	81.70	-37.60	-3.10	-16.80	0.75
4	36	24	328.05	Freddie Freeman		ATL	1B	94		371	54	111	59	47	89	0.298	15	5	70	24	1	182	2	8	3	59.60	58.70	9.20	54.40	47.20	70.20	48.40	3.90	91.05	-89.30	-2.20	-24.60	1.50
4	40	26	324.85	Joe Panik		SF	2B	92		400	61	123	44	32	51	0.306	6	2	93	21	3	167	1	6	2	22.80	44.20	4.20	60.80	31.90	92.90	42.00	9.60	83.65	-50.60	-1.00	-16.80	1.20
5	41	27	324.15	Nolan Arenado		COL	3B	93		377	55	108	60	18	54	0.286	16	1	65	25	3	185	1	12	4	62.00	60.30	2.20	55.20	18.20	64.90	49.80	7.80	92.25	-54.20	-1.10	-35.10	1.90
5	44	30	322.25	Adrian Gonzalez		LAD	1B	92		372	54	105	64	39	72	0.283	15	1	65	26	0	175	1	10	6	59.60	63.60	1.00	53.80	39.40	64.60	51.20	0.00	87.70	-71.90	-0.50	-29.10	2.85
5	45	31	319.30	Troy Tulowitzki		COL	SS	80		322	56	100	57	35	65	0.311	16	1	63	21	1	170	1	7	4	64.40	56.80	1.40	55.70	35.30	62.70	41.20	2.10	85.20	-64.70	-0.70	-22.20	2.10
7	64	44	301.10	Norichika Aoki		SF	OF	83		367	58	107	32	35	35	0.292	3	16	88	13	3	135	6	6	1	10.40	31.90	31.00	58.20	35.00	87.80	26.60	9.90	67.35	-34.80	-6.30	-16.50	0.55
8	77	53	290.55	Mark Teixeira		NYY	1B	88		330	50	79	56	48	77	0.238	20	1	43	16	1	155	1	8	6	79.60	55.80	2.20	49.80	47.80	42.60	31.00	1.50	77.35	-76.80	-0.50	-22.80	3.00
17	162	107	240.85	Josh Reddick		OAK	OF	77		278	33	75	36	28	44	0.271	12	2	47	14	3	131	2	4	3	47.20	35.90	4.00	32.70	28.30	46.90	27.40	9.00	65.25	-43.90	-1.60	-11.70	1.40
23	222	136	215.65	Derek Norris		SD	C	83		320	43	84	34	38	78	0.261	10	1	53	20	1	134	0	8	1	38.40	33.70	2.20	42.60	37.70	53.40	39.20	3.00	67.00	-77.80	-0.40	-24.00	0.65
24	235	142	209.85	Devon Travis	Injured - sore left shoulder - is on the 15-day disabled list Projected Return 6/20/2015	TOR	2B	83		302	37	81	32	19	55	0.269	7	7	55	16	3	126	3	8	4	29.60	32.30	13.80	36.60	19.40	54.90	31.80	9.30	62.80	-55.00	-2.90	-24.60	1.85
31	310	179	181.10	Matt Wieters		BAL	C	71	6/16/2015 2:10 PM Matt Wieters is not in the Orioles lineup on Tuesday.	237	30	59	33	20	48	0.251	11	1	35	13	0	107	0	6	3	44.40	33.00	1.80	29.70	20.00	34.80	26.20	1.20	53.30	-48.10	-0.40	-16.50	1.70
Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	AB	R	H	RBI	BB	K	BA	HR	SB	1B	2B	3B	TB	CS	GDP	SF	HRV	RBIV	SBV	RV	BBV	1BV	2BV	3BV	TBV	KV	CSV	GDPV	SFV
			3736.95	Avg Stats/Total Values				1106		4,385	639	1,247	602	443	789	0.284	153	55	819	248	27	2,008	24	92	41	612.00	602.10	110.00	638.90	442.80	818.60	495.00	82.20	1003.90	-788.80	-23.60	-276.60	20.45
			3020.90	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				851		3,433	510	1,003	480	338	579	0.292	116	46	668	197	23	1,594	20	68	30	464.40	480.30	91.80	509.90	337.90	667.70	393.00	68.40	796.75	-579.20	-19.80	-205.20	14.95

Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	HLD	L	SHO	QS	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	HLDV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	BSV
1	1	1	465.18	Clayton Kershaw		LAD	SP	19		137.3	103	35	32	27	164	7	2.11	10	0	0	3	1	15	0	411.90	51.50	0.00	-64.40	164.40	0.00	-16.50	-103.40	2.40	-27.10	46.38	0.00
5	46	15	318.83	Gerrit Cole		PIT	SP	20		121.1	108	44	40	35	118	8	2.99	9	0	0	5	0	14	0	363.30	43.50	0.00	-80.40	117.60	0.00	-25.00	-107.60	0.90	-34.60	41.13	0.00
6	56	18	306.51	James Shields		SD	SP	20		131.6	121	57	52	32	126	16	3.58	7	0	0	7	1	12	0	394.80	37.00	0.00	-104.60	125.60	0.00	-33.00	-120.70	1.50	-31.50	37.41	0.00
8	72	23	293.90	Gio Gonzalez		WAS	SP	19		118.0	111	45	42	43	119	8	3.18	9	0	0	5	0	13	0	354.00	43.00	0.00	-83.40	119.30	0.00	-24.50	-111.40	0.90	-43.30	39.30	0.00
13	127	40	257.70	Lance Lynn	Injured - tightness in right forearm - is on the 15-day disabled list Projected Return 7/1/2015	STL	SP	18		110.1	103	44	41	42	106	8	3.34	7	0	0	5	0	12	0	330.30	37.00	0.00	-81.60	105.70	0.00	-26.00	-102.50	0.60	-41.50	35.70	0.00
20	196	69	225.39	Chris Heston		SF	SP	21		101.5	101	43	39	29	83	8	3.47	7	0	1	5	0	10	0	304.50	36.00	0.00	-78.20	83.20	0.50	-23.00	-100.60	0.60	-28.60	30.99	0.00
21	202	72	223.02	Drew Hutchison		TOR	SP	19		111.0	113	55	51	36	104	15	4.09	7	0	0	6	0	11	0	333.00	35.50	0.00	-101.00	103.90	0.00	-31.50	-113.40	0.90	-36.30	31.92	0.00
24	234	93	210.05	Alfredo Simon		DET	SP	18		111.8	96	55	51	36	73	10	4.08	7	0	0	6	0	10	0	335.40	34.00	0.00	-101.40	72.90	0.00	-30.00	-96.40	0.60	-35.80	30.75	0.00
24	240	96	208.80	David Robertson		CHW	RP	38		38.1	27	12	11	10	53	4	2.69	2	22	0	2	0	0	4	114.30	11.00	111.00	-22.80	52.70	0.00	-11.50	-27.40	0.00	-10.30	0.00	-8.20
25	248	101	205.70	Drew Storen		WAS	RP	43		38.8	31	13	12	9	36	2	2.74	3	25	0	3	0	0	5	116.40	12.50	125.50	-23.60	36.40	0.00	-13.00	-30.60	0.00	-8.70	0.00	-9.20
29	288	123	188.92	Ubaldo Jimenez		BAL	SP	24		88.0	80	41	37	39	88	8	3.81	6	0	1	4	0	7	0	264.00	27.50	0.00	-74.60	88.40	1.10	-21.50	-80.00	0.60	-38.60	22.02	0.00
34	334	143	174.10	Santiago Casilla		SF	RP	41		41.0	32	17	16	14	34	3	3.45	3	20	2	2	0	0	4	123.00	13.00	101.00	-31.40	33.60	1.70	-12.00	-32.10	0.00	-14.30	0.00	-8.40
49	485	223	111.23	Hector Santiago		LAA	SP/RP	27		58.1	51	29	27	23	53	7	4.18	3	0	2	2	0	2	0	174.30	14.00	0.00	-54.00	53.00	2.30	-11.00	-51.00	0.30	-23.30	6.63	0.00
Round	Rank	TRank	Value	Name	Inj	Team	Pos	g	News	IP	H	RA	ER	BB	SO	HR	ERA	W	SV	HLD	L	SHO	QS	BS	IPV	WV	SVV	ERV	SOV	HLDV	LV	HV	SHOV	BBV	QSV	BSV
			3189.33	Avg Stats/Total Values				328		1,206.4	1,077	490	451	374	1,157	103	3.36	79	68	6	56	3	107	13	3619.20	395.50	337.50	-901.40	1156.70	5.60	-278.50	-1077.10	9.30	-373.90	322.23	-25.80
			1787.00	Avg Stats/Total Values (active)				230		624.1	534	257	237	194	605	56	3.41	40	68	5	29	2	46	13	1872.30	199.00	337.50	-473.20	605.30	5.10	-147.00	-534.30	4.80	-194.40	137.70	-25.80

callahan  6/18/2015 10:23 AM

Are you punting SB and SBV?  Lorenzo Cain helps in those cats and he's projected well.  I might've dropped Ubaldo or Devon Travis.  DT because he doesn't project well.